Thursday, March 12, 2009

Review: Thirst






Thirst


Ok so here goes my attempt to summarize the documentary "Thirst". The main focus of the the documentary was water privatization, and how it affects communities. The film started off in Cochabamba,Bolivia. Cochabamba is Bolivias third largest city and also one of the poorest. Bechtel, a major company took over the water system, and raised the cost of water 30 to 300%. There were major riots referred to as "water wars" because of this change in prices and the new control over the water system. Snipers along with police were brought in during the riots and a 17 year old boy was killed. The community believed that the people should have a right to decide whether or not the water supply was owned by a company/industry or have it be a human right for all people with no individual ownership. Not only did the documentary also show Bolivia dealing with water privatization, it also focused on a small town in India. Many under-developed countries are struggling with water privatization and can not afford to pay for water. While Bolivia sees privatized water as bad, India looks at it from a different perspective. Since there is little rain in India, people have to take matters into their own hands and harvest the water that they do recieve. India preserves their water by a process called rainwater harvesting. They built ponds to help hold the rainwater, which then goes down stream into village wells to provide water to the community. By the community doing this and local people helping out they are providing "self help" for one another. Local companies can help them with this project since India recieves so little water. A man who lived in the small community of India believed that by starting to harvest rainwater in a small village can then extend on into the country and later into the world. Now onto the United States. The documentary focused on the town of Stockton, California. This town was also going through the process of water privatization. The major of Stockton, Gary Podesto, believed that privatizing the city's water supply would save the residents a lot of money over an extended period of time (around 170 million dollars over 20 years to be exact). This savings would come from not having to pay employees, benefits, insurance, etc. Thames water company was involved with mayor Pedesto and was interested in ownership of the city's water supply. The people of the community on the other hand, disagree. They dont want local companies to own their water supply, they think it should be a common right as a citizen and shouldnt be under someones ownership. Some employees even said that they would refuse to work for local companies and want to remain working for the government. Throughout the documentary it was clear that the majority of the community didnt like the thought of water privatization and thought that the water supply should be a human right compared an ownership.


Discussion:
When we were discussing the film in class some good points got brought up. Sara J mentioned that the council men who come up with the decisions on whether or not the water supply should be privatized, probably have the same views as the mayor, so the majority of the community is not fully represented. The council men are usually volunteers so the point was brought up, why would anyone work for someone or something that they dont agree with? Another idea that was mentioned in discussion was what if the price of water becomes as much as the price of gas? I mean we have seen how expensive gas has been, just last summer it was around $4 a gallon. How would we afford water if it cost that much? There are some ways to get around paying for gas such as walking, riding the bus, riding a bike or carpooling. How would you get around using water? Its a necesity a way of life. Being a college student I know I wouldnt be able to pay that much for water, I dont know what I would do if the price of water was that high, its scary to think about.

My thoughts:
When watching this documentary it got me thinking about our water supply. How we seem to have endless amounts of water at our fingertips. What if we lost all of the water from the lakes, streams, rivers and oceans and our water supply ran out? If we were put into the same positions as third world countries, what would we do? How would we get our water? What if water prices were as high as the price of gas? Would our country be able to afford it? All of these questions bring about concern for the U.S.. We see other countries such as India trying desperately to preserve their water supply so we know the possibility of not having enough water is there. Personally, I am going to try and conserve water as best as I can, hopefully our water supply wont run out and our country wont have to face water privatization.










19 comments:

  1. Good review, Jessica!
    Personally, I don't know WHAT I'd do if water reached ridiculously high prices such as $4 per gallon! You made a good point saying that there are ways to get around high gas prices, but what about with water? It's not as if we can just stop using water, much less drinking it! I think that the U.S. should make a greater effort to conserve water before we get to the point of being desperate for it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jessica- YAY!! Thanks for the shout out in your blog!! Seriously, one thing I have gotten from this class is to take a step back from the issue, and consider what is going on behind the scenes...for me I was really focused on how underrepresented the community of Stockton was, rather than the actual issue of water privatization. I don't know, I guess we all think differently! Good review! --S

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jessica,
    Good Review! It's hard to imagine having to buy large quantities of water for necessities. I'm glad I live where there is so much fresh water. Hopefully it doesn't come to the point where we have to buy water by the gallon. Interesting topic.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jessica-
    Great job on your review. I really thought that water said a lot. I think that the videos presented in class have opened our eyes to a lot of issues that we have been aware of. I find myself changing as these weeks have been progressing. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jessica

    Wondeful job on your review! I thought of something that you mentioned as well in your discussion. When Sara J was talking about how the councilmen usually support the mayor, I think the only hope for that, is that sometimes they really don't! I know that after our mayor was chosen from my hometown and noone really liked her all that much, the council we had didn't really support her! They wanted to make sure that other views were heard and that both sides of everything were apparent. If we could have more cases like that, it would be much easier to get all points of views across!

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  6. Jessica-- you did a really great review top notch! I loved the way it read, and the question you posed at the end it does seem like we have an endless supply of water but when it boils down our eyes have been opened by the recent readings and video to the reality of how we dont! Yikes! you photo was great and added the the post!:) Keep up the great work!In addition sara j made a great point about thinking about the topics behind the scenes!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jessica- you did a really good job summarizing everything! You also had many good questions to think about! I am going to try and conserve water the best I can as well! Your picture was really good..it pretty much explained the debate perfectly!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh man, I wouldn't know what to do if water reached $4 a gallon either! I remember last summer when gas prices were so high I biked everywhere and saved money by not using my car but there's no way I couldn't use water! It is scary to think about! P.S. when mentioning Sara J don't forget to link her name to her blog;)
    Good review, Jessica.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Jessica!

    Good job getting all the main points of the documentary!
    Discussion was pretty intense in class the other day! I could not imagine if water soon became the price of gas! You really brought it to perspective because yes, we can reduce our use of gas, but water is a necessity of life! It is really scary and hard to think if our country was scares as other countries with water. Good question! Could our country afford it? It would be tough!
    Great review Jessica!!

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  10. Jess,
    I honestly don't know what I would do if the price of my water bill went up much more! I don't think it would even be possible to live away from home! I really hope the price of water doesn't get more then gas..that seems crazy. Good review!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I really liked that you told us that these major riots over water are called "water wars". That was really interesting to me. I also like that you included the different things that other countries are doing in order to conserve water. I think that it is great that in India, people ar harvesting rainwater. That is so smart, and it is really something that the rest of us should do. You brought up a really great point that the council men don't properly represent the community. These men are volunteers, and they chose to work with Podesto, so their views are most likely very skewed. I also like that you questioned what would happen if water prices got as high as gas prices. Water is a necessity, so what would we do if we were no longer able to afford it. Yikes!!! Luckily we aren't at that point yet

    ReplyDelete
  12. Because its not possible to completely run out of water it is bothersome to think about that because the governments, they feel its rightful to control the supply of water. People are already self-conscious about there money right now due to the economy so it's just going to continuously bring up oppositions.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. WOw! I love that pic, it really explains a lot about the water privatization issue. I was very sad to find out that a lot people are going through great lengths just get water when i have a pretty much endless amount of it as well.
    Nice post!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Jessica,
    I liked the question you posed related to putting a price on water: How would you get around using water? It is a vital part of living! We would definitely have to budget for it and sacrifice some of the luxuries in our life, which is scary to think about, given the current recession our economy is in!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think it is so cool that countries come up with the idea of harvesting water, and have such inexpensive ways for saving and using their water resources compared to all of our polluting companies... If only we could think of more simple, eco-friendly solutions!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nice work! It's crazy to think how companies are actually taking over something that everyone has a right to. It's also iteresting to see how areas with little water have comeup with simple ideas to conservse the little water they have.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Good post Jessica! It is great that you really seem interested in this topic! It is very surprising to me that this is even going on? I think it is neat how countries are coming up with ways to harvest their own water. If only the US could think of some solutions of our own!!!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great Post Jessica! All I have to say if the day comes that we are being charged for water I hope that I am not here to see it cause that is just totally insane!! We need water to live! Plus I really dont think it is right to be charged for something like that in the first place...what next will they charge us for...air!! Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete